Is it time to cancel health insurance?

Is it time to cancel health insurance?
concerned woman health insurance premium
concerned woman health insurance premium

Why are Australians cancelling their health insurance?

Private health insurance is going through it’s biggest challenge yet. Prices continue to increase more than normal inflation and many people are left wondering if the cost justifies the value. Our new generation of youthful Australians are either cancelling our of health insurance or not taking it up in the first place mainly because it’s such a significant expense.

The risk here is that if young and healthy people don’t keep the private health insurance age demographic balanced, then the see-saw will tip. Too many senior Aussies with high-cost health requirements means health funds are forced to increase premiums. After all, joint replacements, open-heart surgery, dialysis, rehabilitation, major eye surgery… this is all the expensive stuff. It’s also all the more reason that middle-aged and senior Australians absolutely need private hospital cover.

Of course, health insurance can be a grudge-buy. Handing over hundreds of dollars per month and getting nothing tangible in return can leave the dopamine receptors in our brains firing blanks. It’s no surprise that more young people are dropping out of the health insurance game when they are conditioned to receiving instant gratification. Couple with the fact that young people are generally fit and healthy, how could private health insurance be of use when it’s never required?

There’s a saying in this industry that still rings true: you never need insurance until you do. The beauty of the Australian health landscape (public and private) is that the many props up the few, the young support the aged, and the healthy contribute more than they ought to so that the sickly don’t go bankrupt. We should be proud of this system. The alternative is to go the way of the American health system… let’s not.

Good value health insurance

Building value into your health insurance is a complex yet rewarding outcome to pursue. Value is a broad term. Value in private health insurance means feeling that the rebates and returns are justified by the cost: you hand over premiums each month, you get something valuable for your spend. A lot of insured Australians don’t feel they get very good value, so we’ve decided to put together a plan to help change that before you go ahead and cancel your health insurance policy.

This is the most misunderstood aspect of health insurance. An annual limit is how much you have to spend on a particular extras category before you are capped. The Rebate is how much your fund actually pays out when you make a claim. For example, a policy might have a $500 annual limit per person for Physiotherapy, but may only payout a $23 rebate per Physio visit when you actually make a claim.

Why should you continue to pay the lions share for such services? Especially considering how much you pay into your health fund. It’s no wonder so many people cancel health insurance as a result.

Many of the bigger health funds are known for dangling high annual limits in front of their customers, but being incredibly stingy on the actual rebates. Often a person won’t realise until they go to make a claim, which can be years after a policy is taken out. The point of claim is where a lot of people become upset with their health insurance. Being on a policy with higher rebates mean you hand over less money for the extras services you use most. Higher rebates = Better Value.

Portability

Don’t re-serve waiting periods when you switch to a new health fund or policy

“John was immediately covered for a hip replacement in private hospital because he had already served his waiting periods for joint replacements on his old policy”

Hospital Cover: Exclusions and medical gap cover

Getting value out of your Private hospital cover policy is considerably more complex. It’s not as simple as how much your health fund pays for any given procedure. Value from hospital cover comes from what procedures are included or excluded, and how much money you hand over to your private doctor and anaesthetist in the way of their Medical Gap fee.

A key change that can reduce your health insurance premiums is to remove high-cost procedures that you likely won’t need (you might be surprised by the number of people over 50 that are still paying for Obstetrics, Pregnancy and IVF). Gold (Top) Hospital cover can also include Psychiatric services, Dialysis, Weight Loss procedures, and many other clinical categories that you may not need to be paying for.

One of the most common reasons people cancel health insurance is when they are hit with a bank-breaking private doctors gap bill after surgery.

Gap Cover can be an overwhelming topic, but it’s really quite simple. When we give health insurance advice to our customers over the phone, explaining Medical Gap Cover is one of the most rewarding ‘a-ha’ moments of the process. Probably the biggest complaint we hear from our customers is when they’ve finally gone an used their hospital cover for private surgery, and they’ve been hit with a bank-breaking doctors gap bill. It is of paramount importance that you understand gap cover terminology and how it works to help avoid this from happening to you.

Knowing your rights before you go in for surgery, and asking the right gap cover questions at the right time can be the difference between forking out thousands of dollars for a private procedure or not. Of course, being with a reputable private health fund that offers recognisable gap cover options to your doctor is just as important. An example of one of Australias most reputable Gap Cover programs is called Access Gap Cover by the AHSA

Premiums: Staying up to date

April 1st every year. Health insurance premiums increase again. Being on a silver or gold hospital cover, or holding a couple/family policy means paying over $400 per month for health insurance is becoming the norm. That’s just not good enough. Coming up with that kind of money can be difficult. More and more Australians are being forced to cancel their health insurance as a result.

We find that the most common reason people are on low-value health insurance policies is that they have remained on the same policy for more than five years. Policies go out of date, people.

The best way to reduce your premiums is to compare health insurance policies with the rest of the market. There are 40 health insurers and new policies are being released almost annually. Staying on top of your health insurance comparisons every 2-3 years is the single most effective way to keep your costs down and your benefits high. It also keeps the health funds on their toes as well, because they are forced to be more competitive when the market is kept healthy by health insurance switchers.

Should I cancel my health insurance?

Fair Healthcare Alliance can help you compare 23 health funds, many of which are not-for-profit. We can help you increase rebates, review hospital exclusions, learn about your Medical Gap Cover, and reduce your premiums. You should certainly undertake this exercise before you cancel health insurance.

It’s impossible to give health insurance advice without speaking to you on the phone, so we’re not going to give you a cheap and indirect online quote. We need to know what’s important to you and what isn’t, what you need and don’t need. Finally, we will help you compare your new policy to your old policy apples-with-apples.

Our customers give us 5-star reviews because we are transparent, honest, and care about you and your family’s need. We walk you through a health insurance comparison and explain everything along the way. Exclusions, excess, ambulance, participating hospitals… you get the picture. Contact us below and we can have a refined, tailored health insurance quote in your hand after a quick chat centred all around you.

Is it time to cancel health insurance?

Founder at Fair Healthcare Alliance

Aaron Savrone, founder of Fair Health Care Alliance (FHCA), is a health insurance expert with over 15 years of experience. Specializing in transparent, customer-focused advice, Aaron launched FHCA in 2017 to address the lack of genuine care in the health insurance comparison space. With a commitment to simplifying complex policies and data, Aaron and the team have earned FHCA top ratings and awards, including a 5-star Google Review score from hundreds of reviews and winner of the Best Insurance Comparison Website by ProductReview 3 years in a row (2023, 2024, 2025).

Table of Contents

    Related health Insurance Articles

    0%

    Select Cover for...*

    Estimated time to complete: 02:50 minutes

    Single
    Just Myself
    Couple
    Just Us Two
    Family
    Just Us and the Kids
    Single Parent
    Just Me and the Kids
    Please select an option.

    Select your State*

    Prices and policy availability are affected by where you live.

    ACT
    ACT
    New South Wales
    New South Wales
    Victoria
    Victoria
    Queensland
    Queensland
    South Australia
    South Australia
    Western Australia
    Western Australia
    Tasmania
    Tasmania
    Northern Territory
    Northern Territory
    Please select an option.

    Do you currently have health insurance?*

    yes image
    Yes
    no image
    No
    Please select an option.

    Who is your current health fund?

    Please select an option.

    Select your Product Type*

    Combined
    Hospital Cover + Extras
    Hospital
    Just Hospital Covers
    Extras
    Just Extras
    Not Sure
    Not Sure
    Please select an option.

    Do you need any of the following covered in a private hospital?*

    These specific categories often require a top level of hospital cover, which is the most costly.

    Pregnancy
    Pregnancy
    Joint Replacements
    Joint Replacements
    Cataracts
    Cataracts
    Dialysis
    Dialysis
    Weight Loss Surgery
    Weight Loss Surgery
    Heart
    Heart
    Psychiatric In-Hospital
    Psychiatric In-Hospital
    None of these
    None of these
    Please select an option.

    Which extras do you require cover for?

    General Dental
    General Dental
    Major Dental
    Major Dental
    Optical
    Optical
    Physiotherapy
    Physiotherapy
    Chiropractic
    Chiropractic
    Massage
    Massage
    Podiatry
    Podiatry
    Other
    Other
    Please select an option.

    Your Government Rebate*

    This is your taxable income before tax. It will affect which health insurance rebate you are entitled to and your policy price.

    Please select an option.

    Great! We've found high-value policies to match your stated needs.

    Enter your details so we can help you refine it further. Our tailored health insurance quote will be fast and 100% obligation free.

    Please enter a valid email address.
    Please enter a valid 10-digit Australian phone number without the country code (+61).
    Your information is important to us. By clicking ‘I accept’ you agree to the Fair Health Care Alliance privacy policy for the sole purpose of providing you with a personalized health insurance quote based on your stated needs. (We don't share your information with any marketing or data companies! Promise)
    You must agree to the privacy policy to proceed.
    Please select an option.